We expect alot the the American Idol men of season 4 because they're just so darn great! Tonight, most played it safe and were disappointing. The band also leaves ALOT to be desired and the music director is OUT TO LUNCH. Here are our reviews of the performances:
Nikko Smith - 5701 - very mediocre performance. He can do better. He may be out this week but if he makes it - do better next week dude!
Scott Savol - 5702 - Scott, Scott, Scott... you are so fantastic, what happened? Again, a mediocre performance from a truly GREAT singer. Scott deserves to make it to next week just because he is sooooo good despite tonight.
Anthony Federov - 5703 - Yes, yes & yes. Polished but safe & a bit boring. We love you anyway and fully expect Anthony to be in the final 6.
Bo Bice - 5704 - Damn that boy can sing!!! We love you Bo! Rock on.
Travis Tucker - 5705 - Very nice performance. Great look. We'll see you next week I'm sure.
Constantine Maroulis - 5706 - We LOVE Constantine. All the makings of a star despite not the best vocal this week. Constantine is HOT HOT HOT!!! He will sell records with, as Simon put it, his "charisma".
David Brown - 5707 - So good but ... wrong song for him. Who's helping these guys pick their songs? Simon, you of all people should know better. Take your band leader and Trump him! (i.e. "You're Fired"). This was a waste of an awesome talent and amazing voice. Please do better next week.
Jared Yates - 5708 - He's a star no doubt. The performance didn't knock our socks off but... he's a star.
Anwar Robinson - 5709 - Talk about turning a sow's ear into a silk purse. Despite the lack luster performance of this lame band, Anwar turned it out. See you next week.
Judd Harris - 5710 - Fun performance but felt like I was in a Vegas lounge. Hope to see you next week but maybe not. Sorry...
Joseph Morena - 5711 - Very good voice. Okay song. Safe performance. We'll probably see you next week.
Mario Vazquez - 5712 - Of course my home boy would turn it out!! We LOVE Mario. Mario, you could really win this competition. You've got it all. The look, the voice, the charisma, the style, the performance ability. And you're just so fun to watch & listen to. See you next week dog.
_____________________________________
Each week we will provide you with performance reviews from a marketing perspective and hope the contestants as well as the fans will find them useful.
Toli Cefail is a veteran marketing executive and musician. She currently is the co-owner of a leading online marketing firm and ad agency.